Risk management

Crosswalk view from above

 

Risk management is a high priority and guides the way in which PwC South Africa is managed.

 

 

Quality and service delivery

Risk

Risks relating to the quality of client service; e.g. audit/non-audit quality of service delivery.

This includes risks relating to:

  • human and technology factors supporting the ability of engagement teams to effectively and sustainably work in a hybrid way, both on-site and remotely; and
  • identifying, and reporting on:
    • increased potential of fraudulent, corrupt practices by clients;
    • increased instances of anti-competitive behaviour by clients (e.g. price gouging); and
    • material misstatement of client financial statements due to quality/availability of audit evidence.

Our response

All of our people undergo mandatory quality training, and our client and engagement acceptance and planning processes are robust. Contracts entered into include a limit to our liability, and approval for ‘high-risk’ engagements must be provided by Risk Management, with assignment of a second partner and real-time risk management reviews. Engagement leaders review each engagement, including client sign-off and overall client feedback. Quality and service delivery form part of our annual partner and associate director appraisal process, and our Risk Management team conducts annual compliance, quality and business reviews.


Culture and values

Risk

Risks relating to adoption by individuals or groups, including joint business relationships/alliance partners and/or member firms, of values or behaviours that are inconsistent with PwC’s core values. 

This includes risks relating to:

  • A changed relationship between leadership and staff due to hybrid working; and
  • sustainability of staff capacity/resilience to operate and deliver quality in times of significant staff movement.

Our response

Our values, culture, purpose, ethics and code of conduct programmes are communicated regularly to our people. Elected champions and helpdesk facilities are available. Third parties and contractors are required to subscribe to our Code of Conduct, unless their own has been reviewed and accepted by us. Incident trends are monitored, and appropriate social media use policies are in place. Ethics, anti-bribery and information security training is mandatory, and breaches of these policies are investigated. Any misappropriation of client data/information, malicious ‘loss’ or disclosure of sensitive client or internal data by members of staff resulting in reputational damage or adverse media attention is considered a serious offence.


Information and cybersecurity

Risk

Risks relating to cyberattacks, resulting in a significant data breach and loss/disclosure of sensitive client (and PwC) data, or disruption of normal services, ransomware and advanced persistent threat campaigns. Failure to safeguard confidential information resulting in data compromise, misappropriation of client data/information, including incidents of bribery and corruption; and major hard data loss — including off-shored or outsourced repositories.

This includes risks relating to:

  • organised and targeted phishing attacks/fraud both on PwC staff and clients working remotely;
  • dependence on staff working remotely to maintain information security standards; and 
  • client information and cyber security standards that are not as mature or resilient as PwC's, resulting in data breaches.

Our response

The necessary information security and access measures are in place to ensure the safeguarding of our information against cyberthreats, including ongoing staff awareness programmes. All staff are required to complete an annual self-declaration of compliance with policies and procedures, and prior to client engagements, staff sign independence and code of conduct confirmations. Disciplinary action is taken in instances of non-compliance.


Regulatory threats to business model

Risk

Risks related to the impact of regulatory change or reform and its potential impact on our business.

Our response

Regulatory developments and their impact on the firm’s strategic priorities are considered on an ongoing basis. There is ongoing risk and quality oversight of regulatory registration and reporting, as well as rotation analysis to comply with rotation requirements. Portfolio diversification, priority account focus, regulatory relationship management and channel choice decisions are all dealt with at senior levels.


Purpose and trust

Risk

Risks relating to issues, especially where public debate contains a moral dimension, which may create significant and continued adverse media coverage and undermine the firm’s positioning on its purpose and trust. 

Our response

Active management of the firm’s external communications, including media relations and social media platforms, is a full-time function. We regularly communicate our gift policy and maintain a gift register. Leadership communicates relevant firm, COVID-19 and market developments and there are robust client, engagement and joint business relationship acceptance processes in place. Ethics training is mandatory.


Talent (People)

Risk

Risks related to the inability to attract, retain and develop key talent as a result of uncompetitive remuneration or lack of investment in and development of our people, which undermines our service capability. Lack of preparation and capacity to deal with major human capital shifts e.g. increased automation. Aggressive competitor/client solicitation of key staff and partners, resulting in the loss of key talent, institutional memory, key clients and revenue.

This includes risks relating to:    

  • employee wellbeing, staff morale and performance; and
  • (re)shaping of employment model and working conditions.

Our response

Reward specialists ensure that our remuneration remains competitive. A transformation strategy aimed at retention is in place. Change strategies are in place around our new finance and people management systems, and an Africa People Partner takes responsibility for the human capital change process. Employee wellness programmes are in place, along with proactive mobility planning to enhance skills development. Talent mapping, succession planning, and critical role identification are focus areas. The Africa Chief Digital Officer takes responsibility for larger-scale change management around business operating solutions, the South Africa Transformation Partner is responsible for the firm’s Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment (B-BBEE) strategy, and the Learning and Development Partner takes responsibility for training compliance. The annual Global People Survey results guide our policies.


Independence

Risk

Risks relating to breach/non-compliance with relevant independence requirements leading to regulatory action and/or client conflict of interest, adverse media coverage and reputational damage.

Our response

Annual independence declarations are mandatory for all of our partners and staff, to ensure that we are objective in all of our dealings with clients. ‘Know your client’/adverse data searches are conducted regularly. There is centralised relationship checking and review of partner rotation data, and the Risk and Quality team is involved in the business operations solutions project. The Independence team monitors and communicates policy changes. The independence team conducts periodic personal independence compliance testing (PICT) on all partners, directors and managers to ensure compliance with independence policies, and financial sanctions are applied where non-compliance is identified.


Legal and regulatory compliance (litigation risk)/breach of sanctions

Risk

Risks relating to breach/non-compliance with laws and regulations other than independence, including:

  • failure to comply with professional institute obligations; 
  • non-compliance by either the firm or its partners with local tax laws; 
  • failure to comply with anti-money-laundering rules;
  • failure to comply with applicable anti-corruption legislation, whether local or international; 
  • litigation following significant troublesome practice matters; and 
  • breach of sanctions (US/EU/UN) resulting in reputational damage, fines and revocation of credit lines.

Our response

Our Risk and Quality function provides mandatory annual training and monitors compliance with policies and standards during internal reviews. Our client acceptance and continuance process requires our teams to ensure the risks related to non-compliance with laws and regulations (including anti-money laundering and anti-corruption legislation) are understood and appropriately considered prior to accepting the engagement. Quality improvement plans are in place for each of our lines of service and we undertake regular updates of policies and standards (e.g. sanctions, insider trading, anti-bribery and corruption etc.). We advocate a culture of doing the right thing, always underscored by our values and code of conduct. In the event of breaches, we have a robust approach to litigation.


Increasingly stringent nationalisation/transformation targets (regulatory change)

Risk

Risk relating to an inability to meet the transformation targets as these become increasingly stringent, including:

  • inability to retain African, Coloured and Indian (ACI) talent to meet ownership and employment equity targets;
  • political shifts — uncertainty around ownership targets, potential revenue loss due to pressure to share work with black-owned firms (deconcentration); and
  • aggressive transformation driven by competitors, creating an environment in which we are unable to respond and compete.

Our response

The Africa Human Capital Partner is responsible for monitoring the implementation of key ACI talent retention plans and pipeline management by the line of service leaders. The South Africa firm’s Transformation Partner drives the implementation of the firm’s transformation strategy, including working with leaders responsible for the various elements of the scorecard (Human Capital, recruitment, procurement, enterprise and supplier development, and corporate sustainability). Scorecards are monitored throughout the year, as are regulatory developments in the B-BBEE space and competitor transformation activity, including B-BBEE scorecard ratings and ownership levels.


Geopolitical or macro-economic

Risk

Risks relating to potential major shifts in the politics or the economy of the territory as well as those related to over dependence caused by both geographic location and client sector; specifically, overdependence on the government clients in high-risk political environments and election cycles, which could lead to a credit rating downgrade; and major sovereign/ client default resulting in major non-payment risk.

Our response

The firm considers political destabilisation/geopolitical disruption risks against its strategies and objectives, to ensure that changes or adjustments are factored in to reduce both the likelihood and impact of the risk. The Africa Risk Council monitors indicators and warnings of risk via the Africa Business Resilience Team and leverages network resources as required. Withstanding short-term setbacks and anticipating long-term trends are intrinsically linked to the operating environment and business strategies across the region. Certain industry sectors will be more impacted than others by political and climatic cycles, which informs geographical and industry profiling and focus. Monitoring PwC business intelligence provides insight into the posture industry leaders will take in the event of enhanced risk across the region.

Plans include identifying territories most likely to be impacted, and reassessing strategic focus; identifying and managing clients likely to be most impacted and strategically reassessing our relationship with them; proactive participation in key industry/sector forums; proactive management/monitoring of debtors; priority account identification and management; building strong client relationships, and internal understanding of market developments, opportunities, and internal resource capacity.


Business continuity and disaster preparedness

Risk

The holistic management process identifies potential threats to an organisation and the impacts on business operations of those threats. This process provides a framework for building organisational resilience with the capability of an effective response that safeguards the interests of its key stakeholders, reputation, brand, and value-creating activities.

Our response

Business continuity is embedded through a virtual network of individuals and teams across PwC Africa. We work with key stakeholders within PwC Africa to build towards ISO 22301 (International Standard for Business Continuity) re-certification from BSI. In line with global requirements, we continue to implement ARCHER for BCM as a single repository of documentation, along with the development of information security leadership and administration. A virtual team of business continuity practitioners operates within each member firm, coordinated centrally. Incident management teams, supported by in-country business continuity staff, coordinate responses to a disruption and provide an organised and timely process and execution of activities, including escalations to incident management teams to manage the event impacting the member firm(s). We leverage our global network’s experience and expertise to reinforce capacity within PwC Africa.

Follow us

Contact us

 Rianté Padayachee

Rianté Padayachee

Media and Communications Specialist, PwC South Africa

Tel: +27 (0) 11 797 5727

Verena Koobair

Verena Koobair

Head of Communications and Societal Purpose Firm Pillar Lead, PwC South Africa

Tel: +27 (0) 11 797 4873

Hide